allboardgames.com
A Carnivore Did It! box art
2025 Ranked #4,367

A Carnivore Did It!

Every suspect has a story. Only one logical chain catches the culprit—unless this case has two, or three, or a very convincing herbivore.

Animals Cooperative Game Deduction Scenario / Mission / Campaign Game

Players

1-5

Play time

20 min

Age

8+

Complexity

1.77/5

Rating

7.11

Easier to teach Highly interactive Deep strategy

Overview

At a glance

Is this game right for my group?

ABG editorial scores on a 1–5 scale.

Teachability 4.5/5

Easier to teach

Replay value 4.8/5

High replayability

Interaction 5.0/5

Highly interactive

Player scaling 4.5/5

Scales well

Strategic depth 3.8/5

Deep strategy

Player control 4.8/5

More strategic control

Setup time About 5 min
Teach time About 8 min
Table footprint Medium
Campaign commitment About 6 sessions
Recommended edition A Carnivore Did It! – Horrible Guild English Edition
See all 18 specifications

How it plays

How does it play?

Arrange suspects and statements, determine which claims are true or false, and cooperatively identify the guilty animals across two thousand logic cases.

Core mechanisms

Key systems that shape the decisions players make.

Read the full game description

A Carnivore Did It! is a cooperative deduction game built from compact logic-grid mysteries. A case specifies how many culprits are hiding among the suspects and how many statements are truthful. Players place the chosen animal cards and statement cards, then test claims such as whether another suspect is telling the truth or whether a carnivore committed the crime. Every clue constrains the rest of the case, and only one solution fits all of them. Twenty difficulty levels grow from quick introductory puzzles to seven-suspect investigations with conditional statements, multiple culprits, and trickier truth patterns. A decoder helps prepare and check cases, while a campaign links investigations and rewards efficient solutions. With two modes and two thousand configurations, it works as a solo brainteaser or a lively one-to-five-player discussion.

Browse all classifications

Shopping

Where to buy

Compare verified product links, then confirm the edition, shipping, and availability with the retailer.

Videos (1)

How to play

Now playing Video

Photos (4)

Game detail 1 of 4

Photo

Editions

Language and publisher variants currently recorded in the catalog.

Edition Year Language Publisher / Region
A Carnivore Did It! – Horrible Guild English Edition 2025 English Horrible Guild / US

Game and edition data

All specifications (18)

Play and group

Players
1–5
Play time
20 min
Age
8+
Complexity
1.8/5
App
None app

Practicalities

Setup time
About 5 min
Teach time
About 8 min
Teardown time
About 5 min
Table footprint
Medium

Campaign and continuity

Campaign commitment
About 6 sessions
Group continuity
Optional
Resettable
Fully Resettable

Edition and product

Recommended edition
A Carnivore Did It! – Horrible Guild English Edition
Language
English
Region
US
Availability
Current
Edition type
Retail
Current edition
Yes
Credits and catalog connections

Credits

Designers

2
Daumilas Ardickas Urtis Šulinskas

Artists

1
Cecilia Lonnie

Publishers

1
Horrible Guild

Linked items

No published linked games yet.